Tornado Cash, a decentralized smart contract protocol built on the Ethereum blockchain, was sanctioned in 2022 by the US Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) for its role in laundering over US$7 billion worth of illicit funds since 2019.
The sanctions initially led to a drop in Tornado Cash use, weakening its ability to provide anonymity. However, transactions on the platform continue, reflecting the mixed effectiveness of sanctions on decentralized networks and highlighting the challenges in regulating these systems, a new research paper by the Swiss National Bank (SNB) says.
The SNB working paper, released in August 2024, assesses the impact of OFAC sanctions on Ethereum communities and actors, with a particular focus on Tornado Cash.
Tornado Cash is a cryptocurrency mixer operating on the Ethereum blockchain that facilitates anonymous transactions by obscuring the origins, destinations, and counterparties of funds, without attempting to identify their source. The service receives various transactions, mixes them, and then transmits them to their intended recipients. While its primary purpose is to enhance privacy, it has also been used by illicit actors to launder stolen funds.
In August 2022, Tornado Cash was sanctioned by the US OFAC for money laundering. This includes over US$455 million stolen by the Lazarus Group, a North Korea state-sponsored hacking group. These sanctions were significant because they marked the first time a decentralized, non-custodial entity had been targeted, raising questions about the effectiveness of such regulatory actions.
The SNB study analyzed the immediate and lasting impact of these sanctions on Tornado Cash, noting a sharp decline in the value of its governance token, TORN, which dropped by 60% within the few days of the announcements.
There was also a significant decrease in Tornado Cash’s transaction volumes post-sanctions, with a drop in average weekly transactions by 72%.
Deposit volumes fell by 74%, from an average of 1,184 weekly deposits before the sanctions to approximately 307 weekly deposits afterward. Similarly, withdrawal volumes declined by 69%, from an average of 1,093 weekly withdrawals to about 341 weekly withdrawals. These reductions a significant decline in user engagement.
User diversity, measured by the number of unique addresses interacting with Tornado Cash, also dropped significantly, following patterns observed with transaction volumes. This suggests a lasting impact on the protocol’s usage and the privacy it offers.
Despite the initial decline, the SNB paper notes that the net flows into Tornado Cash contracts eventually recovered, with the number of Ethereum blocks containing Tornado Cash transactions increasing over time. Moreover, the proportion of non-cooperative blocks (those including Tornado Cash transactions) generally rose over time, suggesting continued support from network participants.
This is despite the fact that priority fees (extra fees paid by users to prioritize their transactions) are consistently lower for non-cooperative blocks compared to cooperative ones. This indicates that economic motives are not the primary driver behind the decision to cooperate with sanctions and that non-cooperation is often motivated by philosophical beliefs.
Decentralized blockchain-based crypto mixers like Tornado Cash present unique challenges for regulatory enforcement. These services use smart contracts that autonomously run on the blockchain, providing high levels of anonymity and privacy, and their global accessibility and distributed infrastructure make them resilient to enforcement efforts.
To this day, Tornado Cash remains operational and continues to be used for money laundering, experts report. According to blockchain analytics firm Elliptic, more than US$100 million in ether from the HTX/HECO heist of November 2023 has been laundered through the platform since March 13, 2024. Elliptic attributes this theft to the Lazarus Group, based on various attributes of the hack and the subsequent movement of funds.
Cryptocurrencies are increasingly being used to obscure the origins and movement of illicitly obtained funds. Blockchain analysis firm Chainalysis estimates that nearly US$100 billion has been transferred from known illicit wallets to conversion services since 2019. The highest amount recorded was in 2022, with US$30 billion identified.
Featured image credit: edited from freepik
The post SNB Study: Tornado Cash Case Highlights the Challenge of Regulating Decentralized Services appeared first on Fintech Schweiz Digital Finance News - FintechNewsCH.
Full story here Are you the author?
You Might Also Like
The Top 11 Fintech Startups in Switzerland in 2024
2024-09-05
11 fintechs made it to this year’s TOP 100 Swiss Startup list, an award organized by Venturelab.
The 2024 ranking features in total 100 Startups, Yokoy is once again the highest ranking fintech.
Highest fintech newcomer this year is Calvin Risk on rank 44.
Of the 11 fintechs 5 were repeats from the 2023 startup ranking and 6 were newcomers.
Meet the 11 Swiss fintechs that made the TOP 100 Swiss Startups 2024 list:
Yokoy Group AG (#3)-1
Your expenses and company credit cards on autopilot
Relai AG (#24) unchanged
Relai is Europe’s leading Bitcoin app, made in Switzerland
Unique AG (#32) -1
Supercharge Your Team With Unique FinanceGPT
Numarics AG (#33) new
Switzerland’s digital accountant
Calvin Risk (#44) new
Risk management platform for AI algorithms
Aktionariat AG (#51) -11
ZKB bietet neu den Handel und die Verwahrung von Crypto an
2024-09-04
Ab dem 4. September 2024 können Kundinnen und Kunden über die Zürcher Kantonalbank Kryptowährungen rund um die Uhr direkt im ZKB eBanking oder ZKB Mobile Banking Crypto handeln.
Die Bestände der Kryptowährungen werden dabei in die bestehende Depotsicht integriert. Vorerst stehen Bitcoin und Ethereum zur Auswahl.
Crypto Verwahrung
Kryptowährungen nutzen die Blockchain. Mit den Chancen und Risiken dieser Technologie beschäftigt sich die Zürcher Kantonalbank schon seit Längerem.
2021 war die Bank beispielsweise an der Emission der weltweit ersten digitalen Anleihe an der SIX Digital Exchange beteiligt, 2023 wickelte sie als Joint Lead Managerin im Rahmen eines Pilotprojekts der Schweizerischen Nationalbank die Ausgabe digitaler Anleihen mit digitalem Zentralbankgeld ab.
Alexandra Scriba
Neue Schweizer Crypto Assets-Ökosystem Studie der Hochschule Luzern
2024-08-21
In der Schweiz und Liechtenstein hat sich in den letzten Jahren ein diverses Ökosystem rund um Investitionen in Crypto Assets entwickelt.
Auch in den letzten zwölf Monaten ist dieses stetig gewachsen und hat an Vielfalt hinzugewonnen. Die Regionen Zug und Zürich beherbergen die grösste Anzahl von Unternehmen. Einen aktuellen Überblick gibt die neueste «Crypto Assets Study» der Hochschule Luzern.
Zwischen Juli 2023 und Juni 2024 haben sich die Preise und die Marktkapitalisierung von Bitcoin und anderen Crypto Assets erheblich erhöht. Auch das Schweizer und Liechtensteiner Ökosystem für entsprechende Investitionen ist gewachsen – sowohl, was Anbieter als auch was Produkte angeht.
Ende Juni zählten die beiden Länder insgesamt 359 Unternehmen, die Produkte und Dienstleistungen rund um
Crypto Wealth Report: Integration of Cryptocurrencies Boosted by Institutional Interest
2024-08-08
Cryptocurrencies are increasingly being integrated into traditional finance, driven by both retail and institutional interest. Financial institutions are embracing tokenization and institutional investors are increasingly entering the cryptocurrency market.
Bitcoin, in particular, is emerging as a valuable diversification tool in wealth management, highlighted for its low correlation with traditional asset classes and its strong growth performance, a new report by Bitcoin Suisse, a Swiss crypto services provider, says.
The inaugural “Crypto Wealth Management Report”, released in July 2024, looks at the historic performance of bitcoin, showcasing the crypto’s position as a potential powerhouse within diversified portfolios. The report explores the key drivers behind the performance of
Eurex Launches Ether Derivatives
2024-07-18
Eurex expands its crypto derivatives portfolio with the launch of FTSE Ethereum Index Futures and Options as of 12 August 2024. Following the launch of FTSE Bitcoin Index Futures and Options in 2023, this is another major milestone in Eurex’s ambition to offer secure access to cryptocurrencies in a regulated market environment.
Robinhood to Acquire Bitstamp For $200 Million in Cash
2024-06-07
Robinhood has entered into an agreement to acquire Bitstamp, a global cryptocurrency exchange. Bitstamp was founded in 2011 and has offices in Luxembourg, the UK, Slovenia, Singapore, and the US.
Acquiring a global exchange will significantly accelerate Robinhood Crypto’s expansion worldwide. Bitstamp holds over 50 active licenses and registrations globally and will bring in customers across the EU, UK, US and Asia to Robinhood.
This acquisition will introduce Robinhood’s first institutional business. Bitstamp has been trusted by its institutional clients for reliable trade execution, deep order books and industry-leading API connectivity. With Bitstamp’s other institutional offerings like white label solution Bitstamp-as-a-service, institutional lending, and staking, Robinhood will enter
Launch of the Swiss4 Application, Combining Financial Services and Lifestyle
2024-04-23
Swiss4, a financial player founded in Geneva in 2020, announces the launch of its application combining financial services and high-end lifestyle management services.
Entirely designed, developed and hosted in Switzerland, the app guarantees security and ease of use for its customers, deposits in CHF held with the Swiss National Bank (SNB).
The multi-currency account (CHF, EUR, GBP, AED, and SGD), alongside the MasterCard World Elite card, allows for everyday financial transactions worldwide without being impacted by significant currency exchange fees on these currencies. The application also includes a digital concierge service designed to provide customers with the best possible leisure and travel support. Swiss4 is distinguished by high service standards and accessibility, inherited
Tags: Blockchain,Featured,newsletter
